Very much unlike her mother, Cherish Nottinger is a thief; her pet Chupacabra, Xolo, follows her around everywhere. Before Deathwish, there was a picture of her and Promise sitting on top of her mother's piano. After Deathwish, the picture was put away.


She has Promise's eyes, which are violet like " wildflowers in spring." Her chin is pointed, and her face is wider and her nose is thinner than her mother's ; she also shows a single dimple when she smiles. Cherish's hair frames her light brown skin just so, falling just past her shoulders; it is black, straight, and parted precisely down the middle.


Cherish's father is unknown, but is obviously of Spanish or Latin American origin. As is evident in Cherish's looks as well as her spanish-peppered speach patterns.